Apple
Apple Watch Series 11 GPS 42mm, Space Grey aluminium, black sport band
Apple Watch Series 11 GPS 42mm, Space Grey aluminium, black sport band
Our Verdict
The most complete smartwatch here, provided you carry an iPhone, and useless if you do not.
Why it's number one: Four published reviews of this exact watch (Expert Reviews, Trusted Reviews, TechAdvisor and Macworld), more than any other product on this page, alongside the deepest smart-feature set in the category.
It is close: The Garmin vívoactive 6 is 0.07 behind and scores higher on our own rubric, on the strength of multi-day battery against the Apple Watch's single day. It has one published review to the Apple Watch's four. The deciding factor is the phone in your pocket: the Apple Watch is iPhone-only, and for an Android owner the Garmin is not second place, it is the answer.
For an iPhone owner nothing else integrates like this. Notifications you can actually act on, contactless payments, a mature app library, and the tightest link between watch and phone of anything in the category. The costs are the same ones the Apple Watch has always carried. It charges every night, which complicates sleep tracking more than Apple admits, and it is locked to iPhone: there is no Android version, so half the market cannot use it at all. Its owner record on Amazon UK looks thin next to Garmin's, but that is because Apple splits its listings across sizes, cases and straps rather than because few people own one. For an iPhone owner it is the pick; for anyone else it is simply not an option.
Owners is our reading of this listing's Amazon UK owner rating (exceptional rating, substantial record), shrunk toward the category average when the record is thin. Critics averages 4 published reviews. Tick marks show the category average.
How we scored it
Each measure is marked against the category's rubric, where 10 is the best you can buy, 8 is strong, 6 is basic but sound and 4 falls short. The bars show that mark on the Top7 scale (a 6 reads as 7.0, an 8 as 8.5); the notes quote the rubric mark.
- Health tracking 8.5 (rubric 8): A broad everyday health sensor set. Less depth on training load and recovery than Garmin.
- Battery 5.5 (rubric 4): Charged nightly, the shortest runtime in this list by a wide margin.
- Smart features 10.0 (rubric 10): Full app library, payments and actionable notifications; the best of any watch here, on iPhone.
- Build 9.3 (rubric 9): Aluminium case with Apple's finish and strap ecosystem.
Critic scores: Expert Reviews 5/5 · Trusted Reviews 4.5/5 · TechAdvisor 4.5/5 · Macworld 4/5
Pros
- + The tightest phone integration of anything here
- + Notifications you can act on, not just read
- + Contactless payments and a mature app library
- + Excellent owner rating
Cons
- − iPhone only: it cannot pair with an Android phone
- − Needs charging every night, which complicates sleep tracking
- − More expensive than every non-Apple pick here
- − Training data is shallower than Garmin's